ALL-TIME AWARD WINNERS
2012
| Name | Team | Postseason Award |
| Tommy Grady | Utah | Russell Offensive Player of the Year |
| Joe Sykes | San Jose | Riddell Defensive Player of the Year |
| Jeff Hughley | Philadelphia | J. Lewis Small Ironman of the Year |
| Ron James | Utah | NET10 Coach of the Year |
| Matt Sauk | Utah | NET10 Assistant Coach of the Year |
| Jared Perry | Chicago | NET10 Rookie of the Year |
| Kenny Spencer | Spokane | AVITAE Kicker of the Year |
| Kent Richardson | Philadelphia | RevHoney Defensive Back of the Year |
| Jesse Schmidt | Iowa | Cutters Wide Receiver of the Year |
| Kyle Young | Arizona | Spalding Offensive Lineman of the Year |
| Joe Sykes | San Jose | Game Tape Exchange Defensive Lineman of the Year |
| Tommy Grady | Utah | National Guard MVP of the Year |
| David Hyland | Utah | Guard Community MVP of the Year |
| John Dutton | Cleveland | Al Lucas AFL Pulse Hero Award |
| Dave Cutaia | FOX40 | Official of the Year |
2011
| Name | Team | Postseason Award |
| Aaron Garcia | Jacksonville | Russell Offensive Player of the Year |
| Vic Hall | Chicago | Riddell Defensive Player of the Year |
| PJ Berry | New Orleans | J. Lewis Small Ironman of the Year |
| Kevin Guy | Arizona | NFL Network Coach of the Year |
| Matt Sauk | Utah | NFL Network Assistant Coach of the Year |
| Maurice Purify | Georgia | Aaron's Rookie of the Year |
| Carlos Martinez | Georgia | NAPA Kicker of the Year |
| Maurice Purify | Georgia | The Big Game Breakout Player of the Year |
| Kenny McEntyre | Orlando | Al Lucas AFL Pulse Award |
| Anthony Jones | Dallas | Cutters Wide Receiver of the Year |
| Richard Ranglin | Kansas City | Spalding Offensive Lineman of the Year |
| Cliff Dukes | Tampa Bay | Game Tape Exchange Defensive Lineman of the Year |
| Nick Davila | Arizona | National Guard MVP of the Year |
| Shawn Hochuli | | Official of the Year |
2010
| Name | Team | Postseason Award |
| Chris Greisen | Milwaukee | Russell Offensive Player of the Year |
| Gabe Nyenhuis | Tulsa | Riddell Defensive Player of the Year |
| DeJuan Alfonzo | Chicago | J. Lewis Small Ironman of the Year |
| Rod Windsor | Arizona | Spalding Rookie of the Year |
| Gabe Nyenhuis | Tulsa | Russell Lineman of the Year |
| Les Moss | Jacksonville | UBU Sports Head Coach of the Year |
| Danny White | Arizona | UBU Sports Assistant Coach of the Year |
| Chris Gould | Chicago | Kicker of the Year |
| Tom McCabe | | FOX40 Official of the Year |
2008
| Name | Team | | Postseason Award |
| Chris Jackson | Philadelphia | | Offensive Player of the Year |
| Dennison Robinson | Chicago | | ADT Defensive Player of the Year |
| Will Pettis | Dallas | | Ironman of the Year |
| Matt D'Orazio | Philadelphia | | Champs QB of the Year |
| Mike Brown | Philadelphia | | Al Lucas Hero Award |
| Colson Weatherington | Dallas | | Lineman of the Year |
| Donovan Morgan | Chicago | | Rookie of the Year |
| A.J. Haglund | San Jose | | Kicker of the Year |
| Mike Wilpolt | Cleveland | | Coach of the Year |
2007
| Name | Team | Postseason Award |
| Siaha Burley | Utah | Offensive Player of the Year |
| Greg White | Orlando | ADT Defensive Player of the Year |
| Will Pettis | Dallas | U.S. Army Strong Ironman of the Year |
| Greg White | Orlando | Lineman of the Year |
| John Dutton | Colorado | Al Lucas Hero Award |
| Mark Lewis | Austin | Kicker of the Year |
| Brett Dietz | Tampa Bay | Rookie of the Year |
| Charles Frederick | Kansas City | Rookie of the Year |
| Matt Nagy | Columbus | Russell Athletic Team Award |
| Doug Plank | Georgia | Coach of the Year |
| Shy Anderson | Dallas | Executive of the Year |
| Tom Benson | New Orleans | Founders Award |
| Chicago Rush | | Commissioner's Award |
| Philadelphia Soul | | Commissioner's Award |
| Utah Blaze | | Support Staff of the Year |
2006
| Name | Team | Postseason Award |
| Jerald Brown | Columbus | ADT Defensive Player of the Year |
| Damian Harrell | Colorado | Offensive Player of the Year |
| Randy Gatewood | Arizona | U.S. Army Ironman of the Year |
| Kenny McEntyre | Orlando | Al Lucas Hero Award |
| Remy Hamilton | Los Angeles | Kicker of the Year |
| Colston Weatherington | Dallas | Lineman of the Year |
| Ben Nelson | San Jose | Rookie of the Year |
| Will McClay | Dallas | Coach of the Year |
| Shy Anderson | Dallas | Executive of the Year |
| Kurt Warner | | Founders Award |
| Utah Blaze | | Support Staff of the Year |
| Utah Blaze | | Commissioner's Award |
2005
| Name | Team | Postseason Award |
| Damian Harrell | Colorado | Offensive Player of the Year |
| Kevin Ingram | Los Angeles | U.S. Army Ironman of the Year |
| Silas Demary | Los Angeles | ADT Defensive Player of the Year |
| Silas Demary | Los Angeles | Lineman of the Year |
| Remy Hamilton | Los Angeles | Kicker of the Year |
| Troy Bergeron | Georgia | Rookie of the Year |
| Doug Plank | Georgia | Coach of the Year |
| Dick Sullivan | Georgia | Executive of the Year |
| Jon Bon Jovi | | Founders Award |
| John Elway | | Founders Award |
| Los Angeles Avengers | | Commissioner's Award |
| Nashville Kats | | Support Staff of the Year |
2004
| Name | Team | Postseason Award |
| Marcus Nash | Las Vegas | Offensive Player of the Year |
| Cory Fleming | Orlando | U.S. Army Ironman of the Year |
| Kenny McEntyre | Orlando | ADT Defensive Player of the Year |
| John Moyer | Chicago | Lineman of the Year |
| Jay Taylor | Orlando | Kicker of the Year |
| Adrian McPherson | Indiana | Rookie of the Year |
| Mike Neu | New Orleans | Coach of the Year |
| Rita LaBlanc | New Orleans | Executive of the Year |
| NBC | | Founders Award |
| Chicago Rush | | Commissioner's Award |
| Georgia Force | | Support Staff of the Year |
| Jerry Trice | | Officials' Man of the Year |
2003
| Name | Team | Postseason Award |
| Randy Gatewood | Arizona | Ironman of the Year |
| Chris Jackson | Los Angeles | Offensive Player of the Year |
| Clevan Thomas | San Jose | ADT Defensive Player of the Year |
| Tom Briggs | Dallas | Lineman of the Year |
| Clay Rush | Indiana | Kicker of the Year |
| Travis McGriff | Orlando | Rookie of the Year |
| Todd Shell | New York | Coach of the Year |
| John Elway | Colorado | Executive of the Year |
| Neal Pilson AFL Consultant | | Founders Award |
| Colorado Crush | | Commissioner's Award |
| Georgia Force | | Support Staff of the Year |
| Bill McCabe | | Fox Whistle Most Dedicated Official |
2002
| Name | Team | Postseason Award |
| Greg Hopkins | Los Angeles | Ironman of the Year |
| Mark Grieb | San Jose | Offensive Player of the Year |
| Clevan Thomas* | San Jose | ADT Defensive Player of the Year |
| R-Kal Truluck | Detroit | Lineman of the Year |
| Steve Videtich | New Jersey | Kicker of the Year |
| Clevan Thomas | San Jose | Rookie of the Year |
| Darren Arbet | San Jose | Coach of the Year |
| Todd Merkow | Los Angeles | Executive of the Year |
| Gene Nudo | Arizona | Founders Award |
| Dallas Desperados | | Commissioner's Award |
| Los Angeles Avengers | | Commissioner's Award |
| Indiana Firebirds | | Support Staff of the Year |
| Joseph Rider | | Fox Whistle Most Dedicated Official |
| Chuck Winters | Detroit | The Hero Award |
2001
| Name | Team | Postseason Award |
| Dameon Porter | Chicago | Ironman of the Year |
| Aaron Garcia | New York | Offensive Player of the Year |
| Kenny McEntyre | Orlando | Defensive Player of the Year |
| James Baron | Nashville | Lineman of the Year |
| Brian Gowins | Grand Rapids | Kicker of the Year |
| R-Kal Truluck | Detroit | Rookie of the Year |
| Michael Trigg | Grand Rapids | Coach of the Year |
| Brett Bender | Carolina | Executive of the Year |
| Tim Marcum | Tampa Bay | Founders Award |
| Carolina Cobras | | Commissioner's Award |
| Carolina Cobras | | Support Staff of the Year |
| Lamont Cooper | Oklahoma | Don't Blink! Player of the Year |
| Dameon Porter | Chicago | Breakout Player of the Year |
| Jo Jo Polk | Grand Rapids | Most Inspirational |
| Duwayne Gandy | | Most Dedicated Official |
| James Baron | Nashville | The Hero Award |
| Gary Compton | Milwaukee | Built Ford Tough Man of the Year |
2000
| Name | Team | Postseason Award |
| Hunkie Cooper | Arizona | Tinactin Ironman of the Year |
| Mike Horacek | Iowa | NAYA Offensive Player of the Year |
| Kenny McEntyre | Orlando | NAYA Defensive Player of the Year |
| Sam Hernandez | San Jose | Lineman of the Year |
| Clay Rush | Iowa | Kicker of the Year |
| Chris Jackson | Los Angeles | Rookie of the Year |
| Darren Arbet | San Jose | Coach of the Year |
| Gene Nudo | Arizona | Executive of the Year |
| Ron Kurpiers | | AFL Founders Award |
| Arizona Rattlers | | Commissioner's Award |
| Arizona Rattlers | | Support Staff of the Year |
| Lamont Cooper | Milwaukee | Don't Blink! Player of the Year |
| Ben Bronson | Houston | Breakout Player of the Year |
| Jon Krick | Albany | Most Inspirational |
| Roger McMinn | | Fox Whistle Most Dedicated Official |
| Michael Baker | Grand Rapids | The Hero Award |
1999
| Name | Team | Postseason Award |
| Hunkie Cooper | Arizona | Tinactin Ironman of the Year |
| Eddie Brown | Albany | NAYA Offensive Player of the Year |
| James Baron | Nashville | NAYA Defensive Player of the Year |
| Robert Stewart | New Jersey | Lineman of the Year |
| Mike Black | New England | Kicker of the Year |
| Charles Wilson | Tampa Bay | Rookie of the Year |
| Mike Dailey | Albany | Coach of the Year |
| Gene Nudo | Arizona | Executive of the Year |
| ESPN | | Founders Award |
| Arizona Rattlers | | Commissioner's Award |
| Buffalo Destroyers | | Support Staff of the Year |
| Steve Papin | San Jose | Co-Don't Blink! Player of the Year |
| Kevin Swayne | Iowa | Co-Don't Blink! Player of the Year |
| James Guidry | Portland | Most Inspirational |
| Ed Manning | | Fox Whistle Most Dedicated Official |
| Latish Kinsler | New Jersey | The Hero Award |
1998
| Name | Team | Postseason Award |
| Chad Dukes | Albany | Ironman of the Year |
| Calvin Schexnayder | Arizona | Offensive Player of the Year |
| Johnnie Harris | Tampa Bay | Defensive Player of the Year |
| James Baron | Nashville | Lineman of the Year |
| Kenny Stucker | Milwaukee | Kicker of the Year |
| Oronde Gadsden* | Portland | Rookie of the Year |
| Tim Marcum | Tampa Bay | Coach of the Year |
| Dan DeVos | Grand Rapids | Executive of the Year |
| Billy McGehee | Nashville | Founder's Award |
Orlando Predators,
Arizona Rattlers | | Commissioner's Award |
| Jack Moser | Albany | Athletic Trainer Excellence Award |
| Arizona Rattlers | | Support Staff of the Year |
| Steve Papin | San Jose | Don't Blink! Player of the Year |
1997
| Name | Team | Postseason Award |
| Barry Wagner | Orlando | Ironman of the Year |
| Barry Wagner | Orlando | Offensive Player of the Year |
| Tracey Perkins | Tampa Bay | Defensive Player of the Year |
| Carlos Fowler | Texas | Lineman of the Year |
| Steve Videtich | New Jersey | Kicker of the Year |
| Cory Fleming | Nashville | Rookie of the Year |
| Eddie Khayat | Nashville | Coach of the Year |
| Gene Nudo | Arizona | Executive of the Year |
Nashville Kats,
Arizona Rattlers | | Commissioner's Award |
| Vito "Babe" Parilli | | Founder's Award |
| Bob Mantooth | | Official of the Year |
1996
| Name | Team | Postseason Award |
| Barry Wagner | Orlando | Ironman of the Year |
| Eddie Brown | Albany | Offensive Player of the Year |
| David McLeod | Albany | Defensive Player of the Year |
| Kent Wells | Tampa Bay | Lineman of the Year |
| Pete Elezovic | Albany | Micatin Kicker of the Year |
| John Gregory | Iowa | Coach of the Year |
| James P. Foster | Iowa | Executive of the Year |
| Arizona Rattlers | | Commissioner's Award |
Perry Moss,
Bill Niro, Jerry Kurz | | Founder's Award |
| Jack Baker | | Official of the Year |
1995
| Name | Team | Postseason Award |
| Barry Wagner | Orlando | Ironman of the Year |
| Barry Wagner | Orlando | Most Valuable Player |
| John Gregory | Iowa | Coach of the Year |
| James P. Foster | Iowa | Executive of the Year |
| Don Dizney | Orlando | Commissioner's Award |
Carl Paganelli,
Glen Mazula | | Founder's Award |
1994
| Name | Team | Postseason Award |
| Barry Wagner | Orlando | Ironman of the Year |
| Eddie Brown | Albany | Most Valuable Player |
| Perry Moss | Orlando | Coach of the Year |
| Joe Hennessey | Albany | Executive of the Year |
| Glen Mazula | Albany | Commissioner's Award |
James P. Foster,
Dennis Grapenthin | | Founder's Award |
1993
| Name | Team | Postseason Award |
| Barry Wagner | Orlando | Ironman of the Year |
| Hunkie Cooper | Arizona | Most Valuable Player |
| Danny White | Arizona | Coach of the Year |
| Bryan Colangelo | Arizona | Executive of the Year |
| Bob Gries | Tampa Bay | Commissioner's Award |
1992
| Name | Team | Postseason Award |
| Barry Wagner | Orlando | Ironman of the Year |
| Jay Gruden | Tampa Bay | Most Valuable Player |
| Perry Moss | Orlando | Coach of the Year |
| Eric Leins | Orlando | Executive of the Year |
| Gary Vitto | Detroit | President's Award |
1991
| Name | Team | Postseason Award |
| Milton Barney | New Orleans | Ironman of the Year |
| George LaFrance | Detroit | Most Valuable Player |
| Rusty Fricke | Denver | Kicker of the Year |
| John Corker | Detroit | Lineman of the Year |
| Fran Curci | Tampa Bay | Coach of the Year |
1990
| Name | Team | Postseason Award |
| Thomas Monroe | Pittsburgh | Ironman of the Year |
| Art Schlichter | Detroit | Most Valuable Player |
| Novo Bojovic | Detroit | Kicker of the Year |
| Ernie Stautner | Dallas | Coach of the Year |
1989
| Name | Team | Postseason Award |
| Carl Aikens | Chicago | Ironman of the Year |
| George LaFrance | Detroit | Most Valuable Player |
| Babe Parilli | Denver | Coach of the Year |
1988
| Name | Team | Postseason Award |
| Dwayne Dixon | Detroit | Ironman of the Year |
| Ben Bennett | Chicago | Most Valuable Player |
| Perry Moss | Chicago | Coach of the Year |
1987
| Name | Team | Postseason Award |
| Billy Stone | Chicago | Ironman of the Year |
| Russell Hairston | Pittsburgh | Most Valuable Player |
| Tim Marcum | Denver | Coach of the Year |
|
|
